/
/
Fire Rating Standards for Roof Hatches in the US: A Case for European Compliance

Fire Rating Standards for Roof Hatches in the US: A Case for European Compliance

In the United States, building codes such as the International Building Code (IBC) do not typically mandate fire ratings for roof hatches, a reality that often leads local suppliers to forego offering fire-rated options. This oversight fails to adequately consider the robustness of the European BS EN 1634-1 standard and the potential life safety benefits of specifying fire-rated roof hatches, even when not strictly mandated by code.

Limitations of the IBC Approach

While the IBC does not explicitly require fire ratings for roof hatches, except in limited scenarios like vertical exposure concerns, this perspective is narrow and fails to fully account for the fire safety risks associated with roof hatches. 

The IBC Commentary acknowledges that fire-resistance-rated roof construction is intended to create a barrier to contain fires within the building. However, it contradicts this principle by allowing non-fire-rated roof penetrations like hatches.

The Significance of the BS EN 1634-1 Standard

In contrast, the BS EN 1634-1 standard provides a more comprehensive and realistic assessment of fire hazards associated with door and shutter assemblies, including roof hatches. By subjecting these assemblies to simulated post-flashover fire conditions and evaluating critical failure criteria like integrity, insulation, and radiation, BS EN 1634-1 offers higher safety and reliability.

Furthermore, the BS EN 1634-1 standard mandates that manufacturers implement a quality management system audited by third-party accreditors to ensure consistent production quality matching the tested specimens. This additional layer of oversight is crucial in maintaining the intended fire performance of these critical life safety products throughout their service life.

Life Safety Considerations

While the IBC may not explicitly mandate fire ratings for roof hatches in most scenarios, prioritizing life safety should be paramount for architects, builders, and building owners. By their very nature, roof hatches provide a direct path for fire, smoke, and hot gases to spread vertically between floors, potentially jeopardizing the safety of building occupants and emergency responders.

By specifying fire-rated roof hatches that comply with the rigorous BS EN 1634-1 standard, building professionals can significantly enhance a structure’s overall fire resistance and compartmentalization, even if not strictly required by code. This proactive approach aligns with the fundamental principles of fire protection engineering and demonstrates a commitment to occupant safety beyond code compliance.

European Products and Testing

Suppliers of non-fire-rated roof hatches often claim there is confusion surrounding European roof hatch products marketed as fire-rated in the U.S. market. However, they fail to acknowledge that reputable manufacturers of fire-rated roof hatches can and do test their products to both European (BS EN) and U.S. (ASTM/NFPA) standards, ensuring compliance with the relevant fire safety requirements in their target markets.

Additionally, the principles of fire dynamics and the underlying physics governing fire resistance are universal, irrespective of geographic boundaries. The rigorous testing methodologies and failure criteria established by the BS EN 1634-1 standard are scientifically valid and widely recognized by fire safety professionals globally.

Conclusion

While building codes serve as essential guidelines, they should not be interpreted as the absolute limits of fire safety measures. By specifying roof hatches that comply with the robust BS EN 1634-1 standard, architects, builders, and building owners can demonstrate a higher commitment to life safety, even when not strictly mandated by local codes.

In contrast, we advocate for a more holistic approach that considers real-world fire dynamics, quality assurance in manufacturing, and the fundamental principles of fire protection engineering.

We urge building professionals to carefully evaluate the potential life safety benefits of specifying fire-rated roof hatches that meet the rigorous BS EN 1634-1 standard, transcending the minimum code requirements and prioritizing the well-being of building occupants and emergency responders.

Share this post:

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email

Get in touch

Want to learn more about the projects we offer? 

Related articles

Standard Roof Hatch
SRHP75

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incid idunt ut labore ellt dolore.